Monday, August 30, 2010
"Necessity is the plea for every infringement of human freedom. It is the argument of tyrants; it is the creed of slaves.-William Pitt, British prime-minister (1759-1806)
So the government of the day(s)announced they had a plan - why this thing will cost a mere 100M$ to set up and pay for itself with "user fees" (or as I like to call this stuff taxes"). Contracts were awarded, people hired, politicians celebrated! A 100M$ would insure that we would know for sure if a farmer in Saskatchewan had a .410 coach gun tucked away to clear out the varmints’ in his barn because (here it comes) he will TELL us. This simple (and erroneous) assumption began the long, slow and phenomenally expensive LGR debacle. Why you ask, well here’s a couple of reasons – that farmer in Saskatchewan, that hunter in Quebec, that target shooter in Metcalfe – we all wondered how exactly the registry was going to protect anyone. After all it wasn’t like criminals were going to meekly fill in the forms and tell Police what they had; the LGR was “targeted” towards the non-criminal members of society. When this point was raised it was shouted down by Police Chiefs with the “knowledge is power” argument. Well I am not a police officer but I’m pretty sure rule #1 is to assume that ANY situation is dangerous and to conduct yourself accordingly (regardless of what the LGR says or doesn't say).
So One (1) Billion dollars later we have a long gun registry that tracks the firearms of all Canadians. What happened of course is that the government (in a desperate attempt to get people to use it) caved on the user fees. For One (1) Billion dollars we have now a reasonable competent system in place. However what we don't have in place is increased public safety from criminals nor do are our brave police officers any safer than they were before. What could we done with One (1) Billion dollars? Well we could have hired so many police officers that you couldn’t walk three steps without tripping over one. For One (1) Billion dollars we could of built more prisons where the message of “you use a gun in a crime and you do serious time” would be delivered one day at a time.
Any "necessity" born of Politics is predestined to fail everyone except those who take credit for the idea. Such is the case of the LGR - may it rest in peace.
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
"Mama always told me not to look into the eye's of the sun, But mama, that's where the fun is" - Bruce Springsteen
"The Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corp. estimate that Canadians spend nearly $1 billion a year at a unregulated gambling sites and want a piece of the action. Ontario's cash-strapped government is eager to find new revenue streams to eliminate its massive deficit and fund expensive promises ahead of the 2011 election."
Personally I find phrases like "piece of the action" and "expensive promises" heart-warming as an (over) taxed-payer in this province. What really concerns me though is that in the endless gold rush to grab more and more of our money the government we elected to represent us, our collective values and to set a higher standard for the world to see somehow seems to have forgotten that just because people do or want something it isn't the government’s role to make it easier for them to get it.
Let’s take the 2010 equivalent of a Nazi - that's right I am talking about you smokers! The Nanny state mentality of our provincial and federal governments results in passing laws right, left and centre to insure that practitioners of this particular habit experience the maximum bullshit level in their use of a legal product (and one that the provincial government generates huge tax income from). Despite this incongruity I least get the feeling that they (our fearless leaders) have grasped the concept that smoking, as a rule, is not good for you. Now here's my thesis - neither is gambling. When Bob Rae was in opposition he opined that "gambling was a tax on the poor" and when he was elected famously opened the first Casino in this province. Since that moral flip-flop our governments (remember we elected them) have been hooked on gambling revenue with all the style and class you would expect from a 12 hit a day crack whore working a corner in some urban hell.
If you make gambling easier then, wait for it, PEOPLE WILL GAMBLE MORE. The government knows this and is already rubbing its greedy little hands together in anticipation of all the money they pry from those who can least afford it. Their defence – why people are already gambling on-line – why shouldn’t we get a taste as well (think the Godfather). I can think of reason, ITS NOT GOOD FOR YOU. In other words I expect my government to promote values that we as a society have, crazy old fashioned things like work for your money – don’t expect to “win” it. Manage your debt so you are not an encumbrance to those in your life; don’t assume that we, as a group of hardworking individuals, are somehow responsible for the various miscreants our entitlement based social welfare system creates.
I am a realist, I know that people will gamble regardless of risk to themselves (and smoke, and drive drunk, own pit bulls, pay "eco" fees etc) and we can't expect (nor should we want) our government to control everything about our behaviour(s) (see earlier Nanny State comment) but at the same time I don't expect them to just give up and jump on the same gravy train either. So here’s the thing Mr. McGuinty, you got it on cigarettes, what is it about about making gambling easier you don’t get? If I walked in and said lets sell smokes in schools you would (justifiably) have me burned at the stake. Gambling destroys families, causes chaos and death – why in any god’s name would our elected representatives want to promote this through making access easier?
There are times I believe that I cannot be cynical enough to truly understand the depth of greed and culpability our “leaders” are capable of….
Monday, June 28, 2010
"The most violent element in society is ignorance.” - Emma Goldman
What to do? Perhaps a new concept in the "Survivor" franchise with the "Black Block" dropped onto some desert island with everyone getting the essentials (hatchet and waterproof matches). There they can prove the veracity of their "philosophy" by not depending on each other for anything (plus unlimited smashing opportunities). I would suggest that a monthly fly-over showing the growing pile of skulls would pretty much get the point across that there never was any point at all pretty well.
If that sounds a little harsh it is. Put it it this way - imagine that instead of changing into their "Black Block" clothes in the middle of otherwise peaceful protestors they changed into Nazi or KKK outfits. They would be summarily pounded into corn meal by those same "peaceful" protestors in the same time it took me to write this sentence. Read your history, the Nazis employed the same tactics when they were known as the "brown shirts". Society was repelled then and we are repelled now, after all - what is the difference? If the "Survivor" idea doesn't catch on lets make peace with the North Koreans and stage the next G20 there. I am sure that society would be wide open and welcoming to the "Black Block", or how about the Iranians, or the Chinese or.. well you get the picture.
This rant started with a quote about the relationship between ignorance and violence. This is not a debate about left vs right - ignorance is universal, violence is universal. What is required is the will to stand up to those who embrace ignorance and violence as ends to themselves. So next time your protesting something and somebody next to you decides to break a window or something please understand that if you do nothing you are complicit. If at that moment you take action, do something, anything to change the outcome then from my view you have established the legitimacy of your point of view. As citizens of a democracy this power resides in all of us and no amount of police or security will ever replace it.
Monday, March 15, 2010
The Last Day of Your Life Is Like Any Other Day (except shorter)
Ask anyone with a terminal condition facing an ugly end if they would like to die relatively free of discomfort or die horribly and in pain and I’m pretty sure that unless they really believe that their God wants them to suffer before their reward they will opt for option “A”. For years caring and committed doctors have warned their terminal patients that if they take too many pills it might be fatal thus jumping that ethical chasm as smooth as Burt Reynolds in a black trans am with a screaming chicken on the hood. So, why the debate- none of us have any choice about being born into this world (religious belief systems aside) so really who’s business is it how and when I decide to check out of it? (Assuming we are of sound (ish) mind).
Perhaps it is the rise of social media as collaborative phenomena – the pervasive belief that everyone is interested in everything everyone else is doing. After all if we collectively offer up the minutiae of our lives for validation then why wouldn’t we do the same with our deaths? I read recently of services that offer to continue or terminate your Face Book, MySpace etc pages after you die. Not sure about Twitter but it certainly raises some interesting scenarios (still decomposing, its dark, there are bugs in here).
As with most social issues the various interest groups have engaged in the worst levels of demagogy by raising every nightmare scenario possible (it got so bad I had to sit down and watch my copy of Soylent Green again to get a rational perspective). But to what end? When a cat or dog knows it is going to die it will often leave its home, curl up somewhere warm and wait. Jeez – what do they know that we don’t? It is our perpetual arrogance that we are somehow removed from the natural world and the rules under which it governs our existence, however brief, that drives this debate. Imagine the surprised look on everyone’s faces when the truth, the real truth of existence (namely that it ends) is revealed and the moral, ethical, religious, political and philosophical drivers resolve into a simple choice between death with dignity or the surrender of that inalienable right to those with no stake in your particular game.
Saturday, January 23, 2010
"There must be some way out of here said the joker to the thief" Robert Zimmerman
The public protests about Parliament not sitting have predictably come from the same folks who protest everything the government does when Parliament IS sitting. The opposition parties muddle around consumed with their own inner drama (yeah that's you Natural Governing Party or "Liberals" as they like to portray themselves). The biggest flame so far? The British Economist comes out and says Steve's a bad boy. This bold move probably helped the big C's in Quebec for all I know.
Guy on the street? A giant "whatever" seems to be the prevailing reaction. The workings of our government are pretty much a mystery to us (and by mystery I don't mean something cool and slick with a space age crime lab that solves everything in 60 minutes). Everyone complains about the economy, the weather, hockey and repeat once and rinse. Nobody connects what does or doesn't happen in our government with anything meaningful in their own lives. Governments have always known this thus the long tradition of bread and circus type public events stretching back to Rome. Think I'm exaggerating? Wait for a series of bold, visionary and expensive pronouncements to flow like wine from our current government JUST before Parliament sits down again, quelle surprise!
Soon spring will come, snow melts, dog poo reeks, flowers bloom and for some reason I always want to buy a new car. Everything changes right? Will anybody think that democracy was suspended for a while like some third world junta? The truth is we elect a government to do stuff. In retrospect parliament is redundant in the eyes of the current (and past governments) and that might be true except for the annoying fact that without parliament a lot of important "stuff" gets left on the table. I want that stuff voted in so my world can be changed in some meaningful way. As this session goes gently into the night we are witness to the expediency of politics over the the principals that a lot of Canadians voted for. Bad Steve...
“Policies are many, Principles are few, Policies will change, Principles never do.” John Maxwell
Thursday, December 3, 2009
"Russian roulette is not the same without a gun" - Lady GaGa
This morning Greenpeace protestors scaled the roofs of Parliament to unfurl protest banners while one of their fellows buzzed the city in a small plane. As watched the plane (it was maybe a 1000 feet up) I was thinking about the probable outcome if these activities had happened in Washington DC (substitute "rapidly expanding debris field" for plane and "undisclosed number of terrorists" for protestors). In Ottawa - well the plane didn't appear to have F18's on its tail yet and Parliament Hill security had yet to make any move other than to close down access for the rest of us (the non-protestors). Huh, that’s interesting. So the question of the day for me is why do some people get a pass and the rest don't?
There are numerous examples out there of what would appear to selective enforcement of the laws under which we all agreed to live under. One such example occurred today - Natives decided to block highways to protest the removal of their sales tax exemption that the loathsome HST will bring. So far no one from the government is doing anything to restore order. As in the past they will monitor the situation and hope it runs its course. In my worldview I wonder what would happen if I decided to protest the HST and blocked some road here in Ottawa. As an AMAWG (Angry Middle Aged White Guy) I would expect the SWAT team guys to dispatch me post haste so morning commuters can get back to line-ups at Tim's.
What these folks are protesting (Greenpeace, Natives etc) is all fine, I have no issue with anyone’s right to protest because I believe Canadian society can support different views (I am after all an Enlightened AMAWG). The question is does everyone have the same right to protest and does our government treat everyone who does have an opposing view equitably? My view is that the current practice of selective application of consequences for actions has had the effect of reducing our civil rights rather than supporting them.
What I see is application of consequences to groups and/or individuals not based on the rule of law but rather the issue of risk to the government of potential negative publicity. Using the example of the Native versus me road blockade the potential negative publicity risk to the government of enforcing the laws of our land is huge. The only consequence is that everyone else shrugs their shoulders and finds another way to get to where they're going (BTW I am not picking on Natives - EXACTLY the same suspension of civil liberties occurs during any major labour action where the public is involved). On the other hand if I set-up a protest then my muzzling/arrest/gulag poses no risk of negative publicity therefore its ok.
The difference is that everyone agrees that Natives have had and still have a rough go of it in Canada. No argument from me on that point. So we as a society (and by extension our elected officials) look at protests with a tacit combination of understanding and frustration. The examples of this are endless - everyone is concerned for the environment so let’s cut the various groups pushing their particular agenda some slack etc etc etc. What happens though if your opinion on something doesn't happen to fall into the "PC" category - does that mean its worth any less? All I can say is don't try this at home kids - you might figure out that although we are all equal in the eyes of the law we are most decidedly not equal in eyes of those who we have trusted to enforce those laws.
“A people who extend civil liberties only to preferred groups start down the path either to dictatorship of the right or the left.”
William Orville Douglas
Monday, November 30, 2009
Stupid People Give Me Drain Bamage
This subject is interesting to me because we all are, to one degree or another, stupid. I made a particularly bone headed mistake last week that felt dumb when I did it and boy it delivered on that promise in spades. So in the after-burn of that particular flaming taco I consoled myself with the "I’ll be smarter next time" rationalization. I wonder though, are any of us actually smarter with experience or do we simply find new and innovative ways to express our "inner stupid"?
My inner stupid is a wonder to me, despite all my pretensions of some degree of rationality if it wasn't for the golden horseshoes south of the equator I would shuffled off my mortal coil years ago. So my question is smart people smarter or just luckier than the rest of us? Stupid people on the other hand are always judged through their deficiencies of "process' and often in a judgemental manner as if bad luck is somehow earned (and good luck is given?).
I recently reread "The Marching Morons” by Cyril Kornbluth (1951) for a humorous (and somewhat fascist take) on what happens when the stupid people take over the world. The story is as relevant today (perhaps more so) as it was all those years ago. Did I feel smarter for reading it? Not really but I recommend it anyway. It is interesting because it suggests that society will easily adapt to lowered expectations – whoops hasn’t that already happened?
In the end we are all as god made us, smart, and stupid, whatever – in a hundred years everyone who knows will be gone. That’s ok too, perhaps if there is a grand plan somewhere then that part insures that the terminally stupid and dangerously smart can’t really do any lasting damage to the rest of us marching morons…
"Most people would die sooner than think; in fact, they do"
Bertrand Russell